Skip to main content

The grand canyon of Pike State Forest and the value of Ohio’s mature forests

In this article from the Spring 2021 issue of The Trailblazer, hikers explore Pike State Forest along the Scioto Trails and Sinking Spring sections of the Buckeye Trail, uncovering millions of years of geology, rare wildflowers, and lessons about the ecological value of mature forests.

Logged area
Logged area | Photo courtesy of Petra Schmalbrock

A hike through Pike State Forest reveals both a “Grand Canyon” of Ohio geology and the threats posed by logging to the biodiversity and resilience of old-growth ecosystems.

On March 29, 2021, my hiking partner and I went for a hike on the Scioto Trails Section of the Buckeye Trail in Pike State Forest. We started at point #31 (Davis Rd, Bainbridge OH, near Pike Lake State Park) going toward #32. We hike only short sections of the BT at a time, but we never fail to check out the geology and plants while doing so, especially the beautiful flowers in early spring. We followed the blue blazes marking the trail going southwest toward Pike Lake, past a pond, down to a creek and up a ridge to an elevation of 1200ft. Coming down from that ridge the trail meanders below a rock ledge and a gentle slope below it; very pretty! I’m not a trained geologist, but when I see rock outcrops, I’m always curious to learn more, to learn how geologists “read the rock” to interpret the past.

Ohio’s rock consists of sedimentary rocks, which means that—in the distant past—they were laid down from smaller pieces of rock, sand, mud, and calcium deposits that were all pressed and cemented together over a long period of time to make today’s rock. Older layers are generally deeper, while younger layers are higher (except in cases of mountain formation or earthquakes). Here, the rock ledge is the youngest rock, the slope below is older and the bottom of the ravine is the oldest rock seen in this region. On the trail below my boots, I found rocks that looked as though they broke off from the cliff above and tumbled down. The rocks were hard and chunky, feeling gritty like sand—sandstone. Using my interpretive knowledge, I deduced that the gentle slope below the cliff full of crumbling rocks, breaking into small pieces easily to make the slope had to be shale.

On interpretation

Interpretation is a combination of observation and using information that others gathered before you to come up with the natural history of the area. Geologist have named rock types and created maps of rock layers for over 200 years; these are called bedrock maps. For the hike, I used an iPhone app called RockD (free through Apple Store); the app’s bedrock map for the location listed “Maxville Limestone, Rushville, Logan and Cuyahoga Formations” (figure top right). The Mississippian Maxville limestone was deposited 320 Million years ago in a shoreline, nearshore, or off shore environment. It has high calcium content making limestone. It is underlain by the Logan Formation that formed from sand which eroded from the geologically older Catskill and Pocono highlands and washed into river deltas, to become thick layers of hard sandstone. These geological events and subsequent rock formations are what makes up the cliff ledge we see today. Below the Logan Formation is the shale-dominant Cuyahoga Formation, making the gentle slope seen below the ledge. But where is the limestone? As we walked on, we saw a rare snow trillium near a small creek (pictured below). Snow trillium likes to grow in calcium rich soil. A little rock picked up near the trillium had a tiny fossil, so that must be limestone that formed from the calcium carbonate shells of sea creatures; it was washed down the creak from Maxville limestone above.

As we descended into the ravine, we come across a number of sandstone slabs with riffle marks. I have seen these in other areas where Devonian Berea sandstone is exposed (pictured to the left). These soft sediment deformations are widespread in the lower part of the Berea. So, we have walked from the Mississippian era into the late Devonian era, about 30-40 Million years back in time. At the bottom of the ravine, at 900ft elevation, just above the creek bed we found more shale. This was Ohio shale that was deposited about 370 Million years ago. We hiked another 30 million years back in time. We called this very scenic little ravine the “Grand Canyon of Pike Forest”. Over its 300-ft elevation change, the “canyon” covers about 50-60 million years of rock layers. OK, that’s not as much as the “real Grand Canyon,” but pretty good for Ohio, and the spring wild flowers are spectacular!!! And the flowers even tell you about the kind of rock.

The Forest

The following day, March 30, 2021, my hiking partner and I hiked a little loop trail in the State Park. There, we came across two signs alerting hikers of the park’s management of its “mature trees.” We had recently listened to some lectures and read books about oldgrowth forests, and learned about how special these now rare habitats are. Looking at magnificent ancient trees is fascinating. They are often the widest and tallest trees forming the top of the canopy. They have thick, twisted and gnarly limbs, just like our bent and wrinkling bodies as we age. Some of the old trees shed bark, as if balding. Looking beyond individual old trees, an ancient, undisturbed forest also contains great diversity—many different tree species of different ages and sizes, with native shrubs in the understory. Old forests also have diverse herbaceous ground cover, and even though this is only 1% of the biomass, the ground cover makes up 90% of the diversity. Especially in early spring before trees leaf out, there is a profusion of blooming spring flowers.

Research has shown that naturally evolved old-growth forests have greater diversity and numbers of insects and snails [1], frogs and salamanders [2] and birds that feed on the insects and the many different plants. The State Park’s forest had many large trees, mostly tulip trees that can get up to 500 years old, and oak and hickories that can reach 300-450 years of age. The trees we saw were old, but not exactly ancient. For the trees to be considered ancient, they would have to at least date back to the 1500s or 1600s. Most forests in Ohio had been logged by the 1930’s. So, we suspected that what the Forest Service meant by “mature trees” was that they were “ready to harvest”. Sure enough, the second sign confirmed just that; 77 acres had been logged and sold for $131,400 in 1999 (worth $215,496 today) and has continued to be logged since.

Onward to Sinking Springs

Later that day, we hiked on the BT Sinking Springs Section starting at point #1 (campground/dam) toward point #3. From the road, the trail climbed up the ridge, initially through nice second-growth forest. But then we reached the devastation of recent logging. The Buckeye Trail had disappeared from sight; bulldozers had churned up the ground, and in place of the big trees were just stumps and tons of woody debris everywhere. As trail maintainers and hikers, we know what comes next. The scarred earth will be covered with thorny, brambly plants that are most often invasive plants. In worst cases, landslides may occur. We already found multiflora rose and barberries. Invasive Trees of Heaven (they really should be called “Trees of Hell”) will come next; it is the trailmaintainers’ nightmare. What’s worse is the disappearance of living space for many native, forest dwelling creatures and plants.

The bulldozers ripped up the shrubs and herbaceous ground cover used by small mammals and birds to hide from predators. They disturbed and compacted the soil, and left unnaturally large amounts of coarse woody debris. With the large tree canopy gone, the soil temperature will increase and decrease the moisture. Salamanders live in the moist, cool leaf litter of forests; they cannot live in the environment left after logging. Shadeadapted plants cannot grow there. Soil-dwelling communities of insects, worms, fungi and microbes will be changed. Soil is exposed and not stabilized by the network of roots. This leads to loss of soil and erosion. The water filtration of the forest, and water quality in the adjacent streams diminishes. Yes, flowers, plants and trees that like more light can thrive. But too often invasive plants will get ahead faster than native plants in such a disturbed environment. Trees will eventually grow, but to grow back into mature forest will take many decades, if not centuries.

Is recovery possible?

Can a logged area eventually recover to the land’s original plant and animal diversity? Research has shown almost twice as many different plant species in 300 year-old compared to 100 year-old forest [3]. Another study [4] in a forest that had been undisturbed for 150 years, compared plant surveys from the 1920’s with surveys from 1974, but showed no significant increase in species diversity; there had been little to no recovery even in 150 years. Anecdotally, my hiking partner and I observed that many native spring flowers are not found in previously farmed, reforested areas even 30- 50 years later. Reasons may include several native flowers’ slow seed to bloom maturation, for example, trillium and ginseng can take up up to 10 years; and orchids such as lady slippers and showy orchis require very specific soil fungi. Besides the increased biodiversity and water cleaning properties of mature forests, old trees provide another valuable benefit: they sequester and store carbon dioxide from the air. Old studies [5] assumed that carbon fixation in old forests is less than in young growing forests, because dead, decomposing trees release the carbon again. However, new studies [6] in the last 10 years have shown that old forests continue to sequester and store carbon, because of their larger biomass and because of continued renewal in naturally occurring forest gaps.

The economics of forestry

So what is the economic value of a forest? One that includes not only the dollar value of the lumber, but also the value of all the ecological functions that old forests provide, including controlling run-off, water and air pollution, carbon sequestration and storage, not to mention life-support for the many non-human creatures. If you’re curious about the ecological value of a forest near you, iTree is a program/web-app that allows one to calculate the dollar value of a forest, but one needs to know some detail about the types and sizes of the trees. I don’t have such detailed information for the logged area at Pike State Forest. I can, however, provide an example I read from an unpublished report for such calculations that were done at OSU’s Chadwick Arboretum (62 acres). For the 13,000 mostly younger trees at arboretum (52% had diameters less than 6” and were 30-50 years old.), the value of these trees was $784,000 per year. This calculation included carbon storage worth $732,000, and annual carbon sequestration $13,600/year, reduction of run-off $17,600/year and reduction of air pollution $21,000/year, but not the structural value of that forest. Older, mature trees are worth more as they sequester much more carbon, hold more soil and water than young trees. This is also why planting a young tree to replace an old tree is not an equivalent method of reducing carbon emissions.

I hope more and more people get to hike the Buckeye Trail, and along the way become more aware of all that forests do for people beyond just providing lumber, and most of all, get to enjoy the incredible beauty of mature forests.

Citations

Nature’s Temples, J Maloof, Timber Press Inc 2016
Ecology and Recovery of Eastern Old-Growth Forests, ed AM Barton, WS Keeton, Island Press 2018 

[1] Snails as indicators, chapter 8, in Nature’s Temples, J Maloof, and DD Douglas DR Brown, N Pederson, Land Snail diversity can reflect degrees of anthropogenic disturbance, Ecosphere, Vol. 42, Feb 2013,

[2] Forests and the needs of amphibians, chapter 7, in Nature’s Temples, J Maloof, citing HH Welsh and S Droege, A case for using plethodontid salamanders for monitoring biodiversity and ecosystem integrity of north American forests, Conservation Biology, Vol. 15, June 2001, 558-569 

[3] Herbaceous plant populations and logging, chapter 10, Nature’s Temples, J Maloof, and GF Peterken, M Game, Historical factors affecting the number and distribution of vascular plants in woodlands of Central Lincolnshire, Journal of Ecology, 72, 1984, 155-182 

[4] Herbaceous plant populations and logging, chapter 10, Nature’s Temples, J Maloof, and R Brewer, A half-century old change in the herb layer of a climax deciduous forest in Michigan, Journal of Ecology, 68, 1980, 823-832

[5] “Source or Sink? Carbon Dynamics in eastern old-growth forests and their role on Climate mitigation”, WS Keeton, Chapter 14, 1 in Ecology and Recovery of Eastern Old-Growth Forests, ed AM Barton, WS Keeton, Island Press 2018, including several references to old carbon sequestration, e.g. ME Harmon, WK Ferrell, JF Franklin, effects of carbon storage of conversion of old-growth forest to young forest, Science 247, 1990, 699-702 

[6] same as [5] and many more scientific paper citations in that book chapter

Author

Petra Schmalbrock

Tag
Category
© Buckeye Trail Association